Legal Experts Believe Trump Will Win Legal Battle With Newsom Over Natl. Guard

Democratic California Governor Gavin Newsom’s lawsuit challenging President Donald Trump’s efforts to restore order in Los Angeles is unlikely to find strong support on appeal.

While a district court judge showed some sympathy to Newsom’s arguments on Thursday night, legal experts told the Daily Caller that his challenge is unlikely to succeed. They found Judge Charles Breyer’s reasoning for blocking Trump’s deployment of the state’s National Guard during the riots unconvincing.

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals quickly put a hold on Breyer’s ruling, allowing federal troops to remain in Los Angeles at least until Tuesday, when the next hearing is scheduled. In his 36-page opinion, Breyer—a Clinton appointee—argued that President Trump’s “actions were illegal—both exceeding the scope of his statutory authority and violating the Tenth Amendment to the United States Constitution.”

Josh Blackman, a law professor at South Texas College of Law Houston, told the Daily Caller that the federal government typically “will receive deference” in matters related to security. “I think the court reached out to decide some novel and complex constitutional questions on an expedited basis,” Blackman said. “These are issues that the Supreme Court never weighed in on. I am confident this ruling will not stand.”

Breyer’s reasoning on both procedural and substantive grounds was wrong, former federal prosecutor Joseph Moreno told the DCNF, saying he expects “more reasonable heads will prevail here, if not at the appellate level then at the Supreme Court.”

“With respect to process, Judge Breyer effectively conceded that Governor Newsom lacked a veto power over President Trump’s decision; however, he found that Trump’s notification to Newsom was insufficient despite the two having multiple phone conversations and the order being routed to the California Adjutant General, the commander of the National Guard,” he said.

“Even if you buy the argument that the process was not followed precisely, it is a harmless error and certainly not the basis for declaring an entire Presidential deployment to be illegitimate,” he added.

Trump’s decision relied on a federal statute that allows the president to call the National Guard into federal service when there is a rebellion against U.S. authority or “danger of invasion by a foreign nation.” The statute’s terms are undefined, so Breyer “both decided what the standards meant and that Trump failed to achieve any of them,” Moreno said.

“So we now have an unelected federal judge sitting in San Francisco asserting he can second guess the military decisions of the Commander in Chief, which is the President’s most sacred duty,” Moreno continued. “In terms of both the law and the constitution expect Judge Breyer’s ridiculous decision to be overturned.”

Harvard Law Professor Jack Goldsmith described the “whole opinion slapdash” during a Friday discussion on his Substack. “I was not persuaded by the judge’s second-guessing of the president,” he said. “He was very selective in his definition of rebellion. He was not deferential at all on the president’s power to enforce the laws.”

Related Posts

An elderly woman spent the whole summer and autumn fixing sharp wooden stakes across her roof. Neighbors were convinced she’d lost her sanity… until winter finally arrived.

All summer long—and well into autumn—an elderly woman climbed onto the roof of her house every single day and hammered in sharp wooden stakes. By the time…

My neighbor gave me a bag of these.anyone know what they are How do you eat them…. Check 1st comment 👇

Wild forest roots have been used for generations as emergency food or traditional remedies. In times of scarcity, they helped people survive. But today, eating a wild…

Does Sleeping on Your Right Side Help or Worsen Snoring?

Snoring is one of those nighttime problems that seems simple but is actually influenced by many factors: anatomy, breathing patterns, sleep depth, allergies, weight, alcohol use, and—very…

🎶 This 1964 Hit Broke Records as the MOST Played Song on American Radio—And It’s STILL a Fan Favorite! 😍🔥 Don’t Miss This! ⬇

They thought they’d seen it all. Then a grainy 1965 clip hit the internet and blew everything apart. The Righteous Brothers step onto a small TV stage……

Always put a spoon of sugar in your backyard before leaving the house. I had no idea 👇😨 check in comm:

Exhausted bees are dropping from the sky, and most people step over them like trash. They don’t know that tiny body on the ground might be holding…

Nana’s Simple Trick to Sparkling Ovens

Your oven isn’t dirty. It’s hiding a quiet disaster. Grease baked into corners, fumes you can’t see, and chemicals you’ve been breathing for years. But Nana had…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *